Published on in Parents PACK
In the process of learning more about vaccines, parents — and some healthcare providers — are sometimes surprised to find out that fetal cells are used during the manufacturing process for a few vaccines. This realization can be shocking, particularly as society struggles with the morality of abortion and the use of fetal cells for scientific research.
The cells were isolated from two elective abortions performed in the 1960s. This article addresses some of the most common questions and misconceptions related to how and why some vaccines are made using these controversial cells.
Which vaccines are made using fetal cells?
The vaccines made using fetal cells include:
- Rubella (the “R” in MMR vaccine)
- Chickenpox, also called varicella
- Hepatitis A
- Rabies — one version, called Imovax®
Do vaccines contain parts of fetuses or fetal cells?
In order to grow viruses in the lab, cells need to be made into single cell suspensions, meaning they can no longer be grouped together in the form of tissues or organs. As such, vaccines do not contain “parts of fetuses.”
Vaccines also do not contain fetal cells. Once the vaccine viruses are grown in the cells, the next step in the manufacturing process is to purify the vaccine viruses away from the cells and substances used to help cells grow. If you have ever picked blueberries, you can think of this part of the process as similar. While you are picking, you might get some of the blueberry plant — stems, leaves and even branches — in your berry bucket, but to use the berries, you remove all of those things, so your pie contains only the blueberries (and any other ingredients you choose to add).
This purification part of the process is important for two reasons. The first, and perhaps most obvious, is the manufacturing reason. From a manufacturer’s perspective, an efficient process that results in the purest possible product makes the final product easier to characterize. However, as consumers, the second, and more important, reason matters more. A pure product will not introduce unnecessary components that could trigger immune responses or affect us in other ways.
Why are fetal cells used to make some vaccines?
Viruses reproduce in cells, so to grow viruses for a vaccine, one of the necessary “tools” is a type of cell in which the virus will grow. Viruses will not grow in just any cell type, so one of the first things a scientist needs to do is to figure out what cells the virus will infect in the lab. Because viruses infect people, human cells are a good place to start checking.
The most important benefit offered by using fetal cells was that they were isolated from the sterile environment of the womb. This meant the cells would not be infected with other viruses, and the vaccine produced in these cells would not inadvertently introduce any other viruses.
To find out more about this historic decision, check out the video, Stanley Plotkin: Pioneering the use of fetal cells to make rubella vaccine.
How can cells from the 1960s still be used today?
Cells grown in a laboratory setting are provided with an environment conducive to growth. As the cells reproduce and fill the container in which they are grown, researchers care for them by putting them in new containers and giving them additional nutrients to enable continued growth. As a result, the cells are able to replicate exponentially. Periodically, a portion of the cells will be frozen in liquid nitrogen for long-term storage. The extremely cold temperatures of liquid nitrogen freezers, around -200° C, cause biological activity to cease without killing the cells. Decades later, the cells, if thawed and provided with the appropriate nutrients and environment, will begin to grow again. As the cells grow, the newly produced cells can also be frozen, and the process extended again.
To read more about how this process is done in the laboratory, check out the article about Dr. Plotkin’s work on the Hilleman Film website.
Do more abortions need to be done?
No. Because the cells isolated in the 1960s have been cared for as described above, vaccine manufacturers do not need to seek new cell sources.
My religion is against abortions, so I don’t want to get these vaccines. Are alternatives available?
An alternative version of rabies vaccine is available; however, that is not the case for the rubella, chickenpox and hepatitis A vaccines.
Religious leaders from the major religions, including Catholicism, have evaluated the use of these cells in making vaccines and determined that it is not sinful to accept vaccines made in this manner.
To read more about religious positions related to vaccines, including the use of fetal cells, visit the Immunization Action Coalition’s “Religious Concerns” webpage.
Resources for additional information
- Stanley Plotkin: Pioneering the use of fetal cells to make rubella vaccine
- Are Fetal Cells Used to Make Vaccines?
- The Vaccine Race, by Meredith Wadman — Read a summary of the book and find how to get it in this article from the Vaccine Update newsletter.
- Vaccines and Your Child: Separating Fact from Fiction — See an excerpt, including information related to fetal cells, in this booklet.
Materials in this section are updated as new information and vaccines become available. The Vaccine Education Center staff regularly reviews materials for accuracy.
You should not consider the information in this site to be specific, professional medical advice for your personal health or for your family's personal health. You should not use it to replace any relationship with a physician or other qualified healthcare professional. For medical concerns, including decisions about vaccinations, medications and other treatments, you should always consult your physician or, in serious cases, seek immediate assistance from emergency personnel.